Tuesday, February 27, 2018

Event Report by Shilpa Das Gupta: Advocating for the Invisibles: Defending Migrants’ Rights at the U.S.-Mexico Border and Beyond


In last few years, a huge number of migrants including family and children have been arriving at the U.S.-Mexico border. Violence and prosecution in Central American are the main reasons behind the large number of migration. People have been trying to enter the U.S. to seek protection and a better life. I could attend an insightful discussion on this issue on February 21 in the American University. The discussion was led by Maureen Meyer. She is an AU-SIS Alumni and directs Washington Office on Latin America's (WOLA) Mexico program with a special focus on analyzing U.S.-Mexico security policies and their relation to organized crime-related violence, corruption, and human rights violations in Mexico. She works to promote justice for migrants who are victims of severe human rights violation in Mexico and also organizes several advocacy works related to the administrative and security assistance to Mexico.




















Maureen began the session explaining how difficult the current time is to deal with immigration laws especially with the present administration’s hostile attitude towards Mexico and Central America, policy changes in immigration laws and DACA laws. She stated that though the administration is raising concerns on an increased number of immigration, the reality is that the number of people trying to immigrant has lowered over the years. In fact, they are the lowest since 1972. Unlike the administration's claims, there is no “flood” at the border.

Why do people want to migrate? Firstly, places like Guatemala, Honduras, Nicaragua, and El Salvador has a heavy gang-presence. Crimes like murder, rape, abduction, robbery, and others are extremely high. Police and government do not do enough to protect the citizen. So families want to cross the borders, come to the U.S. for a secured future. Most of the immigrants, after crossing the border, try to talk to the border patrol and seek asylum. But the current U.S. administration does not take the asylum cases in consideration. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) tend to identify them as illegal immigrants rather than asylum seekers. Even in their last press-release, they did not mention anything about asylum seekers. The emphasis was on repatriation of illegal immigrants. (Here’s the press release for reference from DHS official website)


But there was a time when the Obama administration identified economic migration and asylum seekers. Now DHS wants to detain immigrants. There is no right screening at border patrol. They argue that through families, Central American gangs are sending their people inside the U.S. although there is no such evidence. Also, every asylum seeker has the right to talk to the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) but they are not given that chance.

Maureen explained that they are constantly communicating with migrant shelters, the Mexican government and immigration agencies in Mexico to increase protection for migrants. They are talking closely with the migrants, helping them with documentation and other administrative and legal procedures. The aim is to act as a bridge between Mexico and U.S. government. Enhancing the screening process is also a key part of this process. Efforts are taken to push the government to understand the magnitude of the issue and act holistically. It is important to educate the congressmen. If pressure comes from the Congressmen, change can happen. Also, efforts are taken to bring more media attention to this issue.

The three core objectives of WOLA are:
Ø   Focus efforts to mitigate the risk of immigrants
Ø  To limit policy proposals putting migrants at risk
Ø  Protecting migrants from Central America traveling through Mexico.

Keeping the interests of the immigrants at the core, WOLA works at local, state and national levels and acts as a bridge between all these entities. They connect the government bodies to the immigrants and their issues, judicial system and human rights advocates. WOLA also have several supporting organizations. They also partner with thousands of common people around the country who help them in identifying human rights problem. I found a resemblance between the functioning of WOLA and McGlen and O’Connor’s explanation of four key ingredients for the rise of the women’s movement (Woliver, 1993, p. 5):
Ø  Sense of collective oppression (thousands of Central American migrants being deprived asylum or even the basic right to talk to a migration lawyer in the first place)
Ø  An extant organizational base (WOLA has been working relentlessly for the causes of the Central American migrants)
Ø  A communication network (WOLA has a widespread communication network spreading between U.S.-Mexico-Central America. They work with national and local governments, non-profit organizations, immigration offices, immigrants, law and judicial departments. The network ecosystem is large and involves multiple communication stakeholders)
Ø  A critical mobilization event (the DACA bill, ongoing deportation from all parts of the country, President Trump’s hostile disposition towards migrants and his idea of building the wall – all these incidents have triggered major issues for immigrants)

We also discussed collective action and connective action in class. The functioning of WOLA is an example of traditional collective action. The organization coordinates all the key functions. They are active on social media platforms like Facebook and Twitter but they are mainly used to disseminate key information rather than mobilization.

A lot of great information can be found on the below websites. They are also great organizations to get involved as volunteers.

Ø  Washington Office on Latin America (Mexico program): https://www.wola.org/
Ø  The Advocates for Human Rights: http://www.theadvocatesforhumanrights.org/
Ø  National Network for Immigrant and Refugee Rights: http://www.nnirr.org/drupal/border-groups
Ø  Border Network for Human Rights: http://bnhr.org/about/
Ø  Border Angels: https://www.borderangels.org/


No comments:

Post a Comment